Signatures
Goal
Atlantic White Cedar swamps are among the most cherished habitats in the Pinelands. Hiking through tall cedars on a warm summer day or paddling on a Pinelands Stream through a cedar swamp, you instantly feel the majesty of what Henry Charleton Beck called "the Cathedrals of the Pines". They are also critical habitat for the federally endangered Swamp Pink, State Endangered Hessel Hair Streak butterfly, Pine Barrens Treefrog, and home to numerous rare orchids and wildflowers like the Green Wood Orchid, White Fringed Orchid, and Pine Barrens Gentian. The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) has a plan to restore 10,000 acres of cedar across the state; a project to do the first 171 acres is currently being reviewed by the Pinelands Commission.
If the DEP can deliver everything that they say they will, then we will support this plan. However, we need these promises on the record, ideally written into the permit itself. At the very least, we need greater transparency around the areas where the permit application has a significant gap from the likely/intended scope of the project.
The cedar restoration projects are well-funded by settlements from Natural Resource Damage cases. There is still much potential to take a more surgical approach to the tree removal and herbicide application. However, with the following assurances in place, we support this plan as a pilot that informs subsequent stages of the larger plan to restore 10,000 acres of cedar throughout the state. If any of these red lines are violated, then we will share them broadly with the public.
Here are the assurances that we are looking for:
1. Remove less than 1500 cords of cedar with most of the old growth staying in place. The permit application to the Pinelands Commission, as written, allows for up to 2,745 cords of cedar to be harvested. DEP staff have assured us that this would be a worst-case scenario, and that they don't anticipate needing to harvest even half that amount.
2. Report on how much cedar was sold. We need full transparency to ensure that ecosystem needs, not economics, are driving the project.
3. No glyphosate. We recognize that some herbicide use—such as salt of Imazapyr applied judiciously and at the right times of year—may be necessary to ensure the project’s success. However, glyphosate should not be an option—period. DEP staff have not ruled out the possibility of glyphosate use, but have assured Pinelands Alliance that any herbicide use will go through contractors managed by the department—they will not be hired as sub-contractors of the foresters managing the whole project.
4. Never cross the streams. The plans indicate potential locations where stream crossings could be placed. DEP staff do not anticipate actually needing them—and Pinelands Alliance contends that road access in Wharton State Forest should be sufficient to serve the needs of this project—therefore, stream crossings should be taken off the table entirely.
5. Staff labels all the trees for removal and conducts the follow-up surveys. DEP staff have assured us that they will directly label and survey the project—that this task will not be left in the hands of contractors.
6. Provides tours of the area in between phases. The public needs full access—at appropriate times or distances to ensure safety—to inspect the work being done. DEP staff have assured us that oversight will be available as much as possible so that issues can be resolved in real-time.
We, the undersigned of this petition, support the plan to restore Atlantic White Cedar in Wharton State Forest, as long as the conditions described above are followed by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection.
please protect the atlantic white cedar swamps and all of the biodiversity within the ecosystem. i am concerned about excess physical disturbance and use of pesticides. please keep this area as natural as possible. thank you.
I love the Pine Barrens
To ensure we don't lose any of our precious wet lands.
I question the necessity of removing old cedar trees and their stands , so seedlings can be planted in their place. I think all phases of this study and monies exchanged should be transparent to the public.
We need to protect, preserve, and reclaim our natural areas and guard against these destructive threats which contribute to climate disruption.
This is our land, not the loggers. I have seen clear-cuts in Oregon. I cried. We need our trees. They protect us. They are home to thousands of living organisms. Let them live.
Greetings! As a young person, I strongly support protecting our local environment. Thank you for your time, let’s work together. Have a great day.
To protect the pinelands.
our cedar swamps are a major environmental habitat for many native , endangered plants , important habitat for wildlife and the cedar trees are a major aspect of this environment.
Save the Atlantic White Cedar from unwanted destruction!
I want more conservation everywhere
We need to protect our environment to sustain the habitats that support our lives as well as all the wildlidf
The Pinelands are a treasure and we need to be assured no glyphosate is being used that would disturb this precious ecosystem.
Always support Pinelands Alliance. First thought that came to me was tree farming for the state. Saw it happen in Maine when I lived up there. - BILL -.
We ain't gonna have any damn trees left soon! Cherish these and plant a million more!
Destroying a beautiful area for something senseless. Leave the earth grow
Ruining the White Cedar environment as planned is absolutely the wrong thing to do. Not only would the older growth be destroyed, but so would the environment created, the life sustained within the forest and the negative effect it would have on people. We've had enough destruction by the shortsightedness for profit in our state as well as nationally. Stop this absurd idea now.
Preservation
The Pinelands ecosystem must be protected
forest restoration should be done responsibly and use best practices while inflicting minimal damage on the land and vegetation.
To protect old growth cedar
It is good that restoration may occur rather than just invasive removal.
The cedars are beneficial to the Barrens I have lived in the pines most of my life it would be asham to ruin them
Keep the pine barrens pristine and healthy
The pinelands are a national treasure. A very special, unique and important place that we must continue to protect. The many reasons it is special inclue the Freshwater Aquifer, it's unique Biodiversity & Habitats, Agricultural hub, National & International Designations. Natural Pine Barrens water quality and soil chemistry must be protected, the habitats of native and rare species of wildlife and plants, and provides water for millions of people. The Pinelands Protection Act of 1979 recognized the importance of protecting the pinelands. The pinelands needs to continue to be protected, not destroyed and that's what your current plans would do
For support of my native ancestors land
I have lived on the Mullica River most of my life and as an ecologist I do not believe that this methodology of managing the forest ecology is the right one. Clear cutting, using harmful herbicides, compacting the soil using heavy equipment is not the way to success. The State can do better.
There is only one precious Pine Barrens. Though vast it is not infinite. We don't want to be the generation that sees protection of it fail. Please don't think that commercial interests will have any of us in mind.
To protect the white cedars! Protect the land
Leave our public forests alone.
To have my opinion know
Please protect our white cedar swamps!
The need ‘to save’ what is a shrinking source of available life options for this Planet…. The Pinelands are a gift.. and when they are gone…. The are G O N E!
KEEP THE PINES WILD.
I refuse to allow unnecessary harm to our land.
I love our white cedars and the Pine Barrens.
We need to protect the Pines and I don’t trust that this isn’t an economical project without the modifications being asked for. Without protections in place, this reads like a great way for logging companies to be allowed to raze the Pines for profit.
We do need proper restoration, but not for the sake of profits. Transparency is needed to ensure we only cut what is needed and not what feeds someone bank accounts..... Also glysophate is extremely harmful to all forms of life. It effects birds, mammals, and even the local plants we want to preserve.... there has to be a better way....
We need assurance and explanation of why what is proposed.
As a biology teacher, researcher, and concerned citizen who values the last large stretches of relatively undeveloped land in New Jersey, I strongly oppose the cutting of Atlantic white cedar and the use of pesticides in these ecologically sensitive habitats. Atlantic white cedar forests are vital components of our natural heritage, supporting biodiversity and providing essential habitat for numerous native species. These ecosystems are interconnected and support vulnerable wildlife, including timber rattlesnakes and Pine Barrens tree frogs, as well as rare and threatened plant species that depend on the unique conditions of the Pine Barrens. Habitat destruction and pesticide use can disrupt these delicate ecological relationships, threatening the survival of species that are already under pressure from habitat loss and other environmental changes. We should be protecting and restoring these irreplaceable ecosystems, not destroying them. As someone who understands the biological importance of biodiversity and healthy ecosystems, I believe we have a responsibility to safeguard Atlantic white cedar forests and the diverse life they sustain for future generations.
I believe in the cause
Ensure the DEP meets the aforementioned assurances. Keep out revenue-producing corporate groups in the Wharton tract and Mullica basin. Ensure these areas remain pristine. No glyphosate ever.
No cutting down trees in the Pine Lands
I want to save the Pinelands. We do not need people removing the trees and ruining this National treasure. I don't want cancer causing agents being sprayed and killing trees, animals, etc., and polluting the waters
Want to save the pinebarrens for future generations
Save our beautiful pinelands!
Please follow PPA’s recommendations and proceed very carefully. Before commencing the restoration, please have qualified botanists conduct comprehensive rare plant surveys and adhere to the strictest BMP’s to ensure the Pine Barrens’ rare plants including native orchids are not harmed in the process.
Wanting the restoration of cedar to be done properly and without false promises
We must prioritize environmental protections.
Because every bit of destruction of historic endangered old trees, forests, habitats, ecological systems, poisons polluting the water, ground and air and thousands of acres of nature just being destroyed for someone's greedy pockets needs to be stopped. There's no replacing or correcting the damage this is going to cause. If we continue to let things like this happen there will one day be no more nature, trees, land, water or air to sustain us or the anything else. Just like the Lorax, "I speak for the trees."
I am signing so that our assurances will be met in regard to any harvesting of the Atlantic White Cedar. See petition above
Save the forest
To protect the habitat
Must there be a reason for doing the right thing
I oppose heavy machinery and herbicides being utilized in a headwaters stream of the Mullica. Our public lands are not private wood lots or tree plantations for logging interests.
Please save our natural resources, such as trees!!!
We’ve done enough damage to this planet already.
I love trees, nature, and all things good
Take care of our forests
Want to preserve the Pine Barrens as much as possible. No chemicals that will ruin it. No over harvesting.
Protect the Pinelands!
Save our pinelands!!!
Preserve!
Ecological needs before economic ones.
I’m very concerned about the use of herbicides in habitat known to have threatened herbaceous plant species, as well as threatened amphibians.
I believe strongly that all of the pine land alliances assurances must be met in order for the DEP to do their restoration project. If restoration is really what they are after this should be a no brainer.
We must do whatever we can to preserve and protect our Pinelands AND Pine Barrens. The encroachment by OER-building due to the Mount Laurel Doctrine is placing the environmental health of our state.
Save the trees!
I support the petition. Hernicides should never be applied in the Pinealds Reserve.
Atlantic White Cedars are not only my favorite tree, but they are crucial to the Pinelands ecosystem. With AWC’s almost being wiped out by the logging industry, I want what is best for the Pinelands’ ecosystem and for the restoration of Atlantic White Cedars
My wife and I live in the Pines, we never use Roundup or any herbicide, pesticide or inorganic fertilizer due to our sandy soil and the Aquafer underneath it.
Want to preserve the pine barrens, such an important ecosystem in our area. I’ve lived in New Jersey all my life and have enjoyed camping, hiking and using the water ways.
Those trees should be saved!
New Jersey , despite being The Garden State , has been overdeveloped leaving fewer and fewer open space green acres which provide habitats to native plants and animals. The Pinelands should be protected
I think it is exceedingly important to protect habitats and preserve plant and animal species
Leave the Cedars and the Forest alone!
Areas I birdwatch are being directly effected. I think it's crazy to cut these forested areas down. Other already disturbed areas should be replanted with cedar, like old blueberry and cranberry farms.
I care deeply about the environment/nature/wildlife
Preservation and restoration of our lands and waters is key to the future for all of life. Clean air, fresh water and healthy earth is what keeps Humanity going.....
Requested assurances in writing are a must when any “for profit” entity is involved in a project. Protecting the environment has to be a priority.
The pines are precious and belong to the people.
To preserve the woods
It is the right thing to do.
Our pinelands need preservation not exploitation for profit. The scariest words are “ hi, I’m from the government and I’m here to help you.” Don’t trust the government to do the right thing for the people. They only want power and money for themselves.
I don’t trust the government to do a good job!
This cedar forest is unique. It is special. It should be celebrated and visited and touted not cut down irresponsibly. I am very concerned that this is set up to be an industrial style clear cut in conjunction with chemical herbicide.
Just leave the damn trees alone
Concerned environmentalist!
Save the cedars!
Keeping natural areas in Ocean County
It’s the right thing to do
We need to preserve, protect and restore our forests.
This should not be up for debate.
If you kill the land, you kill yourself. We must protect and steward New Jersey’s Pinelands if we care to see tomorrow.
Save a good portion of mature trees and no poisons such as glyphosate.
We need to put pressure on to make sure our forests and wildlife are properly protected
I spent much of my childhood on the cusp of Hammonton and still return to Wharton and its refuge at least monthly, if not weekly. I think trying to restore white cedar is a noble effort but I can’t ignore that there are bad actors nationally in the parklands space right now. I don’t want what may amount to a greenwashed open season on the Pinelands’ lumber. Caution and transparency are key, and I believe the Alliance’s demands here are both reasonable and necessary. The Pine Barrens remains one of the largest undisturbed swaths of forest because of the generations of people who have taken this approach and made their voices heard; I’m happy to join that legacy here.
Support cause of preserving the Pinelands
Restoration with guardrails is mandatory. Across the country there is an attack on public lands, open space and national parks. Oversite and transparency is a must for our wild places to ensure that nature is the sole focus and greed/profit is not a part of the process.
I am a regular hiker, kayaking, and birder in these woods, as well as a resident of the Pinelands, and an Eagle Scout. The current DEP plan is reckless, will cause unnecessary loss of life and habitat, and potentially opens the Pinelands up to illegal logging activities. Atlantic white cedar is worth restoring CAREFULLY and CONSIDERATELY.
Concern for the white cedar and the general health of the pinelands within Wharton.
I am very concerned about logging in the Pinelands and agree with all the requested assutances. I do not want to see commercial logging sneaking in through a loophole.
Trees are life.
Protecting our resources and limiting unchecked contractors intervention.
The Pinelands & our cedar trees are treasures, PLEASE PROTECT THEM!!
The Pinelands Alliance provides thoughtful and well researched efforts to provide protection of NJ's most precious environment. The NJ DEP should respect and incorporate their recommendations.
You cannot replace old growth forests once they are gone.
Protecting the Pinelands is important to our community and the environment.
Preserve our Pinelands while assuring the outlined plan of action.
protect our Pinelands.
The Pine Barrens is the greatest natural resource NJ has, providing clean air and water and recreation to so many people. Let’s NOT make climate change worse - leave the Pine Barrens alone!
I commend the DEP for undertaking this restoration. The Petition provides common sense guardrails for accomplishing the goals of the restoration in a responsible and safe manner.
I strongly believe that unique ecosystem of the Pine Barrens should be protected and preserved now and for future generations.
I care about the environment!
Destroying a forest by another name is still destroying it.
I support preserving the Pinelands and protecting the rivers. No cutting of old growth cedar.
The Pine Barrens are part of our legacy. We have already lost so much. Let us do what we can do to save this precious environment.
I agree with the concerns and requests as outlined. Protection of the pinelands ecosystem should continue to be a high priority in our state.
Defy corporate hedgemony.
Protection of the fragile ecosystem of the Pinelands and herbicide application especially should not be used.
The restoration program is necessary for the long-term sustainability of Wharton State Forest.
Thge plan needed further written promises backed by permits much more restrictive and fully defined. The AWCedars are too precious to allow further action before the plan is more clearly defined, as it also affects all the endangered species and the so valuable aquafer.
I support the knowledge of the Pineland Alliance. I live the pinelands and the previous white cedar.
Restoration Only in Wharton State Forest.
Correct management of the pines is key!
I want to preserve the natural beauty and protect the Pinelands from developers.
Thoughtful restoration of Atlantic White Cedars should be the goal.
Why does the plan include removing 2475 cords of cedar? The plan also features overly-aggressive use of herbicides—treating cedar as a crop to be routinely harvested, rather than the keystone of a functional habitat. We need a more surgical approach, and a written assurance that 10000 acres of cedar will be restored across the state.
I support an Atlantic White Cedar restoration project throughout New Jersey as long as it's conducted in an environmentally appropriate way.
Absolutely NO glyphosate!!! NEVER cross the streams!!! Let the public view what's being done to THEIR forest. Forest health over profit!! Don't destroy Wharton!!!
I support responsible forest management.
This ecosystem is vitally important. Transparency from DEP is essential.
I agree with the petition
I want Atlantic White Cedar trees to be restored, not logged!!! We need to protect our dwindling forests and support their diversity of species. We know how important it is to maintain a healthy population of these trees within the forests they have populated for centuries.
It important to me to protect our woodland and wetlands from development. I am on the Board of a nonprofit land trust and believe farms and other lands be preserved.
The Pinelands must be preserved!!!
Protection of Pinelands species
Preservation of open lands that are essential for the ecosystem there
Save the cedars!
L care about responsible and proper preservation of the Pinelands of New Jersey.
Save the trees and land Conservation
I agree with the petition
Support the agenda.
The commission is in the position of protecting our priceless resources. Instead they may be like all other smash and grab going on today.
Trees trees trees trees ?
The remaining old growth and majestic cedars of the Pinelands are a jewel not to be desecrated. So few of the giant cedars remain as a result of the ship building industry. Today we know better, and must not squander what remains.
Cedars provide incalculable benefits cleaning our water, air, and providing cooling and soil retention etc etc. these are precious trees I thought we had committed to not only saving but replanting in crucial areas.
So important to protect the forests for the sake of future generations, wildlife, and our own health. The earth sustains us all. We must wake up and stop the relentless destruction of natural habitats.
Save the old growth cedars!!!
Preservation creates positive energy for everyone and everything!
PROTECT THE PINE BARRENS!
I believe we are slowly destroying our envionment, habitats for our animals and so many species of trees, plants, etc. We deserve an robust and clean environment and allowing his mass destrution of our cedar trees does not contribute to that objective.
Concessions in this petition are needed. Targeted surgical approach not aerial spraying and machines ripping out cedars and destroying the forest.
Preserve our trees by following the Pinelands Alliance plan. Limit tree removal and control road access in the woodlands .
Protect and preserve the Pinelands and Wharton State Forest
Have walked the Cedar Swamp Trail on Cape Cod. Beautiful and peaceful!
Leave some places natural and peaceful.
Old growth trees are becoming rare and should be protected. More and more forests are disappearing around the state as developers continue to take homes away from native wildlife leaving them nowhere to go. Imagine if you came home one day and your home was missing. The forest should remain in place and left be.
To hold DEP Accountable to their projected plan and protect Wharton Forest
The cedar Forests have a greater value than a mere commodity. Enough is enough!
Don't like logging or herbicides; love trees.
I fully support Atlantic White Cedar restoration but it must be done in a cautious manner minimizing as much as possible the negative impact to surrounding flora, fauna and even the biome itself. These reasonable conditions are a good safeguard.
Nothing is sacred anymore and it’s all about money so am signing and hope so many others do too so there is oversight
Please protect this irreplaceable resource.
We need to protect our most precious natural resource in NJ. The Pinelands and. The aquifer. The State has consistently promised to protect the trees and area of the Pinelands. No logging, no data centers and no pipelines.
This state is overdeloped, nature needs to be protected.
I’m deeply concerned about this approach it seems contradictory to the preservation
Concerned NJ citizen that uses the Pinelands for camping, kayaking, motorcycling and hiking. AW Cedar populations have been reduced over the years and I support true BMPs should be utilized in the DEP reforestation project.
Keep the Pine lands for my grandchildren to enjoy
Glyphosate which is not something that should be used in the PInelands and aerial spraying is unacceptable to control regrowth when each tree of invading species should be individually treated if necessary with a safer product such as horticultural vinegar. Too many cedar trees lost to lumber. I agree that this is a bad plan and is not a surgical approach to both tree removal and herbicide application. Changes are needed to protect our water, ecosystem and health.
Protect the land
I'm an environmental voter!
No need for logging in the pine barrens
We need our trees. I love our trees.
White Atlantic Cedars are majestic and essential players in their ecosystem.
Protect the pinelands.
I believe the proposed allowance of up to 2,745 cords of cedar to be harvested is bordering on a dangerous amount. The ecosystem in the pinelands is tightly compact and fragile in its sustainability processes. Further, under no circumstances should glyphosate be used. There are other less harmful options to considered. In short, the proposal needs more limitations and monitoring.
I support cedar Restoration projects in Wharton State Forest.
Protect & preserve open spaces in the pinelands. The DEP’s job is to protect all living & growing creatures, trees, plants , etc in the pinelands. Please do your job. You are preserving all for the future, remember that.
I want the Pinelands to continue to stay in tact...NO TREE REMOVAL.
This approach poisons the ecosystem much less than the other approach.
Agree with petition
The Pine Barrens are a very unique part of New Jersey and I want to see that does not get disturbed.
After the deforestation tragedy at the Glassboro WMA, there is good reason not to trust NJDEP.
I am signing this because we are in an active environmental apocalypse, making it absolute madness to kill trees when we need to be saving them and objectively masochistic to use glyphosate anywhere, let alone in a forest that desperately needs restoration, not chemical warfare which will destroy multiple lifeforms wholesale.
This project seems unnecessary, as frequent severe storms "restore" the AWC swamps. Removal of black gum and red maple is foolish, as native tree diversity and diverse ecotones are essential for plant and animal biodiversity. I've never seen an unhealthy AWC swamp, other than perhaps closer to the coast where ghost forests exist due to sea level rise and where Phragmites find a way to creep in. The timing and methods for this project need to be strongly considered, and the use of herbicide and large equipment must be avoided in such a sensitive, pristine environment.
I fully support the provisions in this petition. Let's get this done right.
I want to protect and preserve as much open space as I possibly can. We don't need more homes or floors or things. We need more land for animals and trees for oxygen.
I support reducing the amount of cedar to be harvested.
I totally agree with the six assurances listed in the petition. The restoration needs to follow these conditions to maintain our valuable Pinelands for the present and the future. Let's be responsible.
No herbicides, less cut Cedars and transparency on where the cut trees go. We MUST support our environment.
I’m a parent, a veteran and a senior citizen who has always been fascinated by the Pinelands and our precious white cedar. Our environment is very important to me
As a native of NJ who returned after living in CA and OR for over 10 years, I value the natural beauty of this underappreciated state. Don't ruin what we do have!
Cedar swamps are my favorite areas of our forests. I love the coolness (especially on hot days), the foliage, and the beautiful old cedar trees. Please don't destroy these habitats!
It is imperative to protect all old growth forest, especially that which is in Wharton State Forest.
Support reasonable restoration of cedar trees in the Pinelands by abiding by the assurances listed on this petition.
It doesn't make sense to saw down the tress to restore them.......our wildlife and surroundings need to stay undisturbed
there should not be more harm than good in a 'restoration'
The Pinelands is a unique habitat and we have to do everything we can to preserve it.
We must save our natural patrimony for future generations!
Please be an advocate for the white cedars and for all living things that rely heavily upon its existence. Don’t allow it to be a lost resource for future generations. Preserve the remarkable beauty of the Pine Barrens. Let NJ be known as a state that fights to protect and preserve its natural beauty and resources, not trample and destroy them. Let your legacy reflect the good that you did for the environment and the community as a whole.
Seems like a over the top wood grab that for a long time will do more harm than good.
to protect the pines as it is!
The Pinelands--and, importantly, the watershed that lies beneath them--need to be protected. The DEP plan to restore 10,000 acres of cedar trees would be a very strong addition to the recreational value of the Pinelands, whereas any significant logging increase would be a detriment. Please move forward with the DEP plan! Thank you.
As an owner of many acres of old and younger growth Atlantic White Cedar, I favor a conservative ,well thought environmentally sound approach to cedar reforestation.
I understand the importance of maintaining the balance of nature in the Pinelands and trust the recommendations of the Pinelands Alliance.
This petition advocates for reasonable amounts of transparency and a responsible plan of action. The pines are an important ecosystem to protect, not a resource to be irresponsibly harvested. Therefore, any projects done within the pines should be done with the an appropriate amount of responsibility and respect.
We all need to care more about our environment especially when we have an administration that's trying to destroy everything just for profit